What to watch
Three signals tell you which scenario is playing out: (1) Saudi Aramco statement on the Sumed pipeline bypass timeline (the Egypt-Red Sea alternate route can carry 2-3 million barrels per day once redirected, taking 2-3 weeks); (2) any diplomatic resolution of the Iran-US tanker war, especially the September 14 Oman meeting outcome; (3) weekly EIA retail heating-oil surveys, which begin publishing regional prices every Monday in October. A Hormuz reopening would cut heating-oil prices by 20-30 cents per gallon by February 2027 (EIA STEO, Reuters, September 2026).
Propane vs. heating oil vs. natural gas: which is cheapest?
Propane is forecast at $2.80-$3.20 per gallon for winter 2026-2027, up 10-15% from $2.65 last winter. Propane is used for home heating in about 4 million US households, primarily in the Midwest and rural areas. The propane increase is smaller than heating oil because propane is more diversified across refineries, natural-gas processing, and imports. Households on propane will see winter bills of $1,200-$1,800, up from $1,000-$1,500 last winter (EIA STEO, September 2026).
| Fuel | Winter 2026-27 price | Typical winter bill | YoY change |
|---|
| Heating oil (Northeast) | $4.20-$4.80/gal | $3,500-$4,500 | +20-30% |
| Propane (Midwest) | $2.80-$3.20/gal | $1,200-$1,800 | +10-15% |
| Natural gas (national avg) | +8-15% rate increase | $700-$1,200 | +8-15% |
| Electric heat pump | Rate +6-10% | $500-$900 | +6-10% |
Source: EIA STEO September 2026 (heating oil, propane); DOE residential-rate projections (natural gas, electric).
Should households switch to a heat pump?
A cold-climate heat pump costs $5,000-$15,000 upfront but reduces winter heating costs by 30-50% in mild climates and 50-70% in moderate climates. For a Northeast household currently spending $3,800 on heating oil, that means $1,100-$2,700 in annual savings, paying back the upfront cost in 5-10 years. The federal Inflation Reduction Act heat-pump rebate ($8,000 for low-income households, $2,000 for middle-income) plus state programs (Mass Save up to $10,000, NYSERDA up to $8,000, Efficiency Maine up to $8,000) make the conversion financially attractive for many Northeast households. Expect a 15-20% increase in heat-pump installations across the Northeast in 2027 vs 2026 (DOE, September 2026).
What to do this month
Three actions before October 1: (1) book a furnace tune-up ($80-$150) if you have not already; (2) apply for LIHEAP through your state office if your household income is at or below 150% of the federal poverty line — applications open October 1 in most states; (3) if you are considering a heat pump, request quotes from two local HVAC contractors now — installation slots in Q4 2026 are already filling up. Pre-season oil-buy programs (lock in a delivery in August at last-winter prices) are closed, but October deliveries typically run 10-20 cents cheaper than January peak (EIA STEO, DOE, September 2026).
FAQ
How much will heating oil cost in 2026-2027?
Heating oil averages $4.20-$4.80 per gallon for winter 2026-2027, up from $3.95 last winter per the EIA STEO September 2026 forecast.
Will heating oil prices go up this winter?
Yes — heating oil is forecast up 20-30% YoY. The Northeast will see the largest impact, with average household bills rising from $2,800-$3,500 to $3,500-$4,500.
Why is heating oil more expensive this winter?
Three drivers: the Saudi East-West pipeline attack tightening global supply, the Iran-US tanker war adding a shipping risk premium, and the seasonal shift from summer gasoline to winter heating oil.
Can LIHEAP help with heating oil bills?
Yes — LIHEAP provides $300-$1,000 per heating season for households at or below 150% of the federal poverty line. Apply through your state LIHEAP office starting October 1.
Is it cheaper to switch to a heat pump?
For most Northeast households spending $3,000+ on heating oil annually, yes. A cold-climate heat pump cuts winter heating costs 30-70%, paying back the $5,000-$15,000 upfront cost in 5-10 years — and federal + state rebates can cover $3,000-$10,000 of that.
Last verified: September 13, 2026. Sources: EIA Short-Term Energy Outlook September 2026; DOE LIHEAP FY2026 program data; Reuters Saudi-pipeline coverage, September 13, 2026.