Kia Sportage Hybrid — best value
Kia's 1.6L turbo hybrid with 226 hp, standard AWD, and 39 MPG combined. In most cases if you want the same turbo hybrid powertrain as the Tucson, with a similar 10-year/100,000-mile warranty, and a slightly more refined ride. Starting MSRP around $28,000, the lowest in this list and the best value.
Pros
- 39 MPG combined, 226 hp, 10-year/100,000-mile warranty, lowest starting price, strong standard features.
Cons
- Smaller dealer network than Toyota or Honda; less proven than Toyota hybrid; lower resale than RAV4 or CR-V.
Buy if: you want the best MPG-to-price ratio and you do not need the broadest dealer network.
Toyota Highlander Hybrid — best 3-row hybrid SUV
Toyota's 3-row hybrid SUV with a 2.5L four-cylinder paired with two electric motors for 243 hp, standard AWD, and 36 MPG combined. The smart move is if you need a third row and want the MPG savings of a hybrid. Starting MSRP around $42,000, mid-$50,000s for the Limited and Platinum trims.
Pros
- 36 MPG combined (best in the 3-row class), 243 hp, standard AWD, real third row, Toyota reliability.
Cons
- Third row is tight for adults; highest starting MSRP on the list; no plug-in version (the Grand Highlander has a hybrid, but it's a different vehicle).
Buy if: you need a 3-row SUV and want hybrid MPG without going to a minivan.
How to pick the right one
If you want the most well-rounded hybrid SUV with the strongest resale, pick the RAV4 Hybrid. If you want a quieter, more refined ride and a roomier interior, pick the CR-V Hybrid. If you want the longest warranty and the lowest starting price, pick the Tucson Hybrid. If you want the best MPG-to-price ratio and the same warranty, pick the Sportage Hybrid. If you need a third row, pick the Highlander Hybrid. All five use a continuously variable transmission (eCVT) except the Tucson and Sportage (6-speed automatic), and all five qualify for the federal hybrid tax credit where applicable. Test drive at least two before you commit, because the difference between Toyota's hybrid refinement and Hyundai/Kia's turbo hybrid is real, and A practical choice depends on which powertrain character you prefer.
Photo: mariya_m, Pixabay Content License, via Pixabay (https://pixabay.com/photos/mallorca-winding-road-mountains-6957128/)